Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Award under New York Convention

ENFORCEMENT OF FOREIGN ARBITRAL AWARD UNDER NEW YORK CONVENTION


Contributed by Soteris Pittas of SOTERIS PITTAS & CO LLC

31st October 2007

 


In a very recent decision, a Cyprus District Court rejected an application for the recognition and enforcement in the Republic of Cyprus of an arbitral award issued by the Austrian Arbitral Center due to the failure of the applicant to produce the original arbitral agreement or a certified true copy of same.

 

The applicant presented to the Court a copy of the arbitral agreement which was presented as exhibit during the arbitration process in Austria, accompanied by a certificate of the Secretary of the Austrian Arbitral Center, certifying that the said document was photocopy of the copy presented in the said proceedings.

 

The Applicants disclosed to the Cyprus Court that they did not have the original arbitral agreement or any true copy of same and could not comply with Article IV of the New York Convention.

 

The Applicants tried unsuccessfully to persuade the Cypriot Court that due to the fact that the validity of the arbitral agreement was not questioned by the Respondents during the arbitration proceedings in Austria, it was opened for the Cyprus Court to accept the presentation of a photocopy of the arbitral agreement instead of the original arbitral agreement or a certified true copy of same as requested by Article IV of the New York Convention.

 

In addition, the Applicants argued, that the Respondents were estopped from disputing the existence of the arbitral agreement, because the Respondents relied on the arbitral agreement in order to request and obtain a stay of the legal proceedings which they were commenced in Cyprus by the Applicants for the same subject matter.

 

Before the issue of the aforesaid decision, numerous other decisions of Cypriot First Instance Courts, adopted the same strict line of interpretation of the provisions of the New York Convention.

 

The issue will be reviewed very soon by the Cyprus Supreme Court in its Appellate jurisdiction because the Applicants lodged an appeal.

 

In Cyprus, the recognition and enforcement of foreign arbitral awards cannot be considered automatic. Parties should expect that in appropriate cases Cypriot courts will refuse to recognise and enforce arbitral awards. Nevertheless, the “pro-enforcement bias” persists. The Convention’s seven enumerated defences continue to be applied narrowly and the burden of proof remains very much with the party opposing enforcement. In general, Cypriot courts have resisted allowing defences beyond those specified in Article V, although arguments based on procedural considerations have met with some success.

 

 

 

 

For further information on this topic please contact

Mr. Soteris Pittasspittas@pittaslegal.com ) at SOTERIS PITTAS & CO LLC,

by telephone (+357 25 028460) or by fax (+357 25 028461)

 

 

The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advise should be sought about your specific circumstances.

 

PUBLICATIONS 2010

Arbitration in Austria by Dr. Erhard Böhm
13 Dec 2011 17:36

LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND COURTS
• Arbitration in Austria has a remarkable tradition. The first arbit [ ... ]

read more
CYPRUS COURTS & PROCEDURE
09 Dec 2011 23:38

  1. Court System   What is the structure of the civil court system? There are two tiers of co [ ... ]

read more
MINORITY SHAREHOLDERS PROTECTION IN CYPRUS – REMED...
06 Dec 2011 22:43

There is no easy solution, to the problem, which follows from the principle of majority rule, in Com [ ... ]

read more
FRAUD AND ASSETS RECOVERY
06 Dec 2011 17:33

Many fraud cases involve complex corporate structures, incorporated in various jurisdictions some of [ ... ]

read more
Litigation
30 Nov 2011 22:31

  Contributed by Soteris Pittas of SOTERIS PITTAS & CO LLC December 28th, 2009   By a rece [ ... ]

read more
Jurisdiction of Cyprus Courts to issue Interim Inj...
30 Nov 2011 22:06

INTRODUCTION   Cyprus Courts, have jurisdiction to issue any interim order, in all cases, in whic [ ... ]

read more
EU Regulation 44/2001 as a Machinery to pursue leg...
30 Nov 2011 22:03

Due to the accession of the Republic of Cyprus in the European Community (“EU”), Cyprus is bound [ ... ]

read more
Lawyers / Client Confidentiality
30 Nov 2011 22:01

  The foundation of the relationship between a lawyer and his Client, in the effective representat [ ... ]

read more
ВОЗМОЖНЫЕ КОНФЛИКТЫ МЕЖДУ АКЦИОНЕРНЫМИ СОГЛАШЕНИЯМ...
30 Nov 2011 21:58

Очень часто бизнесмены, создавая совместные предприят [ ... ]

read more
МОСКОВСКИЙ БИЗНЕС ЖУРНАЛ
30 Nov 2011 17:38


Июль-Август 2007 № 14(123)
Страницы 52-56
В чем польза трастов [ ... ]

read more
Litigation - Cyprus
26 Nov 2011 22:32

Contributed by Soteris Pittas of SOTERIS PITTAS & CO LLC   Anti-Suit Injunctions December 28 [ ... ]

read more
Memorandum on International Collective Investment ...
26 Nov 2011 22:24

OPEN-ENDED UNDERTAKINGS FOR COLLECTIVE INVESTMENT IN TRANSFERABLE SECURITIES (“UCITS”)
1.1 UC [ ... ]

read more
Arbitration
25 Nov 2011 22:18

INTERNATIONAL MULTILATERAL CONVENTIONS 1. Is your country a contracting state to the New York Conv [ ... ]

read more
Derivative Actions in the Republic of Cyprus
20 Nov 2011 22:11

INTRODUCTION   Cyprus, has adopted the Anglo-Saxon legal system which allows most of English case [ ... ]

read more
Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Award under New Yo...
16 Nov 2011 22:14

ENFORCEMENT OF FOREIGN ARBITRAL AWARD UNDER NEW YORK CONVENTION
Contributed by Soteris Pittas of S [ ... ]

read more
An Applicant cannot abuse the machinery of the Mar...
22 Sep 2011 22:36

Contributed by Soteris Pittas of SOTERIS PITTAS & CO LLC September 23rd, 2010   In a recent  [ ... ]

read more
More Publications 2010

Subscribe to our Publications

Image
We are dedicated to providing our clients with outstanding, highly personalized, legal representation.
Chrysanthou Mylona 10 
3030 - Limassol, Cyprus
© Soteris Pittas & Co LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Image