District Court of Nicosia Rules that a Russian Court Creditor Cannot Seek Directly its Enforcement Against Foreign Defendants

 

30 June 2014

 

The District Court of Nicosia considered if it had jurisdiction to order the registration and enforcement of a Russian Court Judgment on the direct application of a Russian Judgment Creditor against a foreign Judgment Debtor. The Respondent, i.e. the foreign Judgment Debtor, applied successfully for the dismissal of the application for registration and enforcement of a Russian Court Judgment on the ground that the Russian Judgment Creditor does not have a direct right to apply for such recognition and enforcement.

 

Background

 

General Application No. 378/2014 of the District Court of Nicosia, Between VTB Bank v Sergey Taruta

 

Sergey Taruta was represented by Soteris Pittas & Co LLC.

 

VTB Bank filed with the District Court of Nicosia the aforesaid General Application seeking the registration and enforcement of a Russian Court Judgment issued against Sergey Taruta. In the context of the said General Application, VTB Bank obtained on an ex parte basis certain interim orders.

 

Sergey Taruta disputed the jurisdiction of the District Court of Nicosia to register and enforce the relevant Russian Court Judgment, and consequently to issue the interim orders, in that VTB Bank did not have a direct right to seek such enforcement under Article 27 of the Treaty between Cyprus and the Russian Federation on legal assistance in civil and criminal matters, as none of the Applicants and the Respondent had any permanent or temporary residence in Cyprus.

 

The Decision

 

The President Judge of the District Court of Nicosia, T. Economou, accepted the arguments of the Respondent as to the interpretation of Article 27of the Treaty between Cyprus and the Russian Federation on legal assistance in civil and criminal matters, which provides that:

“1. Αn application for the enforcement of a judgment shall be submitted to a judicial authority at the place where the judgment was given. This authority shall transmit the application to the competent court of the other Contracting Party.

 2. If a person applying for enforcement has his permanent or temporary residence in the territory of the Contracting Party where the judgment is to be enforced, the application may also be sumbitted directly to the competent court of this Contracting Party”.

 

The President Judge dismissed the Application of VTB Bank, cancelling also the ex parte interim orders, and held that VTB Bank filed the Application and obtained the ex parte interim orders in contravention of the Treaty between Cyprus and Russian on legal assistance in civil and criminal matters, as VTB Bank, having no residence in Cyprus, does not have a direct right to seek the enforcement of a Russian Court Judgment against a foreign respondent. 

 

For further information on this topic please contact Mr. Soteris FlourentzosDirector at SOTERIS PITTAS & CO LLC, by telephone (+357 25 028460) or by fax (+357 25 028461) or by e-mail (sflourentzos@pittaslegal.com).

 

The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advise should be sought about your specific circumstances.

PUBLICATIONS 2014

CYPRUS: ANTI-SUIT INJUNCTIONS GRANTED BY CYPRUS CO...
10 Dec 2014 11:07

CYPRUS: ANTI-SUIT INJUNCTIONS GRANTED BY CYPRUS COURTS FOLLOWING WEST TANKERS   For long the trad [ ... ]

read more
CYPRUS: SERVICE OF JUDICIAL AND EXTRAJUDICIAL DOCU...
18 Nov 2014 13:06

CYPRUS: SERVICE OF JUDICIAL AND EXTRAJUDICIAL DOCUMENTS IN CIVIL AND COMMERICIAL MATTERS AS PER REGU [ ... ]

read more
Cyprus may no longer be a tax optimised route for ...
13 Nov 2014 08:09

Cyprus India Relations. Cyprus may no longer be a tax optimised route for Indian funds or may it?  [ ... ]

read more
WHERE DOES MANAGMENT AND CONROL LIE?
23 Oct 2014 13:42

WHERE DOES MANAGMENT AND CONROL LIE?               This short note is dedicated to the tes [ ... ]

read more
JUDICIAL SYSTEM AND COURT PROCEDURE
15 Oct 2014 09:33

CYPRUS: JUDICIAL SYSTEM AND COURT PROCEDURE     JUDICIAL SYSTEM AND COURT P [ ... ]

read more
SERVICE OF WRIT OF SUMMONS TODEFENDANT FOREIGN COM...
03 Sep 2014 08:30

CYPRUS: SERVICE OF WRIT OF SUMMONS TODEFENDANT FOREIGN COMPANIES, WHICH HAVE CYPRIOT RESIDENT DIR [ ... ]

read more
ASSET PROTECTION & CYPRUS INTERNATIONAL TRUSTS
25 Jul 2014 10:00 ASSET PROTECTION & CYPRUS INTERNATIONAL TRUSTS

   ASSET PROTECTION & CYPRUS INTERNATIONAL TRUSTS
A.      WHAT DOES ASSET PRTECTION  [ ... ]

read more
Cyprus: A holder of an International Arbitral Awar...
21 Jul 2014 12:24

Cyprus: A holder of an International Arbitral Award, before its registration in Cyprus, under the Ne [ ... ]

read more
Cyprus: The issue whether a person, is signatory t...
21 Jul 2014 12:23

Cyprus: The issue whether a person, is signatory to an arbitration agreement, shall be decided by th [ ... ]

read more
Cyprus: As a general principle, the mere fact that...
21 Jul 2014 12:21

Cyprus: As a general principle, the mere fact that there are multiple parties and multiple issues, w [ ... ]

read more
District Court of Nicosia Rules that a Russian Cou...
30 Jun 2014 12:35

District Court of Nicosia Rules that a Russian Court Creditor Cannot Seek Directly its Enforcemen [ ... ]

read more
CYPRUS: CORPORATE TAXATION - IMPORTANT PRACTICAL Q...
07 Mar 2014 10:49

CYPRUS: CORPORATE TAXATION - IMPORTANT PRACTICAL QUIDELINES IN ASCERTAINING THE PLACE OF EFFECTIV [ ... ]

read more
More Publications 2014

Subscribe to our Publications

Image
We are dedicated to providing our clients with outstanding, highly personalized, legal representation.
Chrysanthou Mylona 10 
3030 - Limassol, Cyprus
© Soteris Pittas & Co LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Image