Lis Alibi Pendens under the Council Regulation (EC) No 44/2001 on jurisdictionand the recognition and enforcement of judgments in civil and commercial matters

Lis Alibi Pendens under the Council Regulation (EC) No 44/2001 on jurisdictionand the recognition and enforcement of judgments in civil and commercial matters

 

Lis Alibi pendens is Latin for ‘suit pending elsewhere.’ Both Articles 27 and 28 of the EU Regulation 44/2001 regulate the existence of lis alibi pendens and related judicial actions. In particular it is a doctrine that regulates the jurisdictional relationship of courts hearing concurrent proceedings involving the same or related causes of action between the same parties pending in the courts of different Member States.

 

In the English case of Ferrexpo AG-and-Gilson Investments Limited and ors[2012] EWHC 721, it was stated that where Article 27 of the EU Regulation is engaged, there is no scope for the operation of Article 28, and that once there are proceedings in different Member States involving the same cause of action and between the same parties, the matter is governed by Article 27 and its mandatory regime.   Hence it can be argued that as per Article 27 of the EU Regulation 44/2001, the Court has the power to stay on its own motion(automatic power) an action filed before it when there is an action filed before the Court of another Member State involving the same cause of action and between the same parties.

 

Likewise of great significance is the fact that Article 27 covers also non Member States which was further analyzed in the case of Ferrexpo.  Specifically the Ferrexpo case is important for the below reasons :

(a)   It was decided that both Articles 27 and 28 are also applied with regards to proceedings pending before non Member States.  

 

(b)   That the application of Articles 27 and 28 of the EU Regulation 44/2001 is not prevented or affected by the legal principles in the decision of Owusu–v- Jackson Case C-281/02.

 

In relation to Article 28 where there are pending related actions before the courts between different member states, which again extends to non Member States as analyzed in Ferrexpo, then the court has the power to stay (discretionary power) the action before it under the precondition that thecourt first seised has jurisdiction over the actions in question and its law permits the consolidation thereof. Hence irrespective of the legal principles in Owusu-v-Jackson Article 28 applies. 

 

In the case of Tatry (1994) CASE C-406/92,the European Court stated that Article 28 of the EU Regulation  needs to be interpreted broadly to cover all cases where there is a risk of conflicting decisions, even if the judgments can be separately enforced and their legal consequences are not mutually exclusive. Additionally, this Article was also the subject of interpretation for Courts who were eager in various cases such as Sarrio SA v. Kuwait Investment Authority [1997] UKHL 49, to analyze the meaning of ‘related actions’.  In the case the Plaintiff issued proceedings in Spain based on contract and while these Spanish proceedings were pending, the Plaintiff also started English proceedings against the same defendant claiming damages (based on tort).  The House of Lords decided that both proceedings involved ‘ related actions’ developing a broad common sense approach hence decided to decline jurisdiction under Article 28.2.  

 

Therefore the above illustrate how the courts have discretionary powers depending on the matter at issue to use either Article 27 or Article 28 accordingly. What is of great curiosity is to see how future courts will interpret Article 27 and Article 28 and whether they will continue to adopt the broad approach as in the case of Sarrio v Kuwait.

 

 

For further information on this topic please contact

Ms. Nada Starovlah (nstarovlah@pittaslegal.com) at SOTERIS PITTAS & CO LLC,

by telephone (+357 25 028460) or by fax (+357 25 028461)

 

The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advise should be sought about your specific circumstances.

PUBLICATIONS 2015

Cyprus: Guidance for Cyprus Courts on the duties o...
28 Dec 2015 08:22

Cyprus: Guidance for Cyprus Courts on the duties owned by directors of a company to the sharehold [ ... ]

read more
Cyprus: Taxation – Amendments on the Double Tax Tr...
22 Dec 2015 15:29

Cyprus: Taxation – Amendments on the Double Tax Treaty between the Republic of Cyprus and U [ ... ]

read more
CYPRUS: Guidance by the Supreme Court of Cyprus on...
14 Dec 2015 12:53

CYPRUS: Guidance by the Supreme Court of Cyprus on “mens rea” for bounced cheques In October 2 [ ... ]

read more
CYPRUS: Double Tax Treaty between Cyprus and Swiss...
09 Dec 2015 07:53

CYPRUS: Double Tax Treaty between Cyprus and Swiss Confederation On 15th October 2015, the Double T [ ... ]

read more
Cyprus: New Procedure for Issuing a Tax Residency ...
07 Dec 2015 14:40

Cyprus: New Procedure for Issuing a Tax Residency Certificates   Tax Department, has recently iss [ ... ]

read more
CYPRUS: NO CAPITAL GAINS TAX FOR IMMOVABLE PROPERT...
27 Nov 2015 06:47

CYPRUS: NO CAPITAL GAINS TAX FOR IMMOVABLE PROPERTIES PURCHASED UNTIL THE END OF THE YEAR 2016    [ ... ]

read more
Tied Agents
23 Nov 2015 08:53

Tied Agents   A tied agent means a person established in a Member State, who, actin [ ... ]

read more
Cyprus: Possible guidance from the English Courts ...
20 Nov 2015 08:04

Cyprus: Possible guidance from the English Courts on the Interpretation of jurisdiction clauses a [ ... ]

read more
CYPRUS: WINDING OF COMPANIES – WINDING UP BY THE C...
18 Nov 2015 11:09

CYPRUS: WINDING OF COMPANIES – WINDING UP BY THE COURT (COMPULSORY WINDING UP)-INABILITY OF [ ... ]

read more
Cyprus: A possible amendment in the Law of Social ...
30 Oct 2015 10:54

Cyprus: A possible amendment in the Law of Social Insurance Debtors   In Cyprus over [ ... ]

read more
Cyprus: Will the proposed amendment in relation to...
29 Oct 2015 08:28

Cyprus: Will the proposed amendment in relation to the reduction of Judges in Family Courts solve [ ... ]

read more
CYPRUS: SERVICE OF COURT DOCUMENTS UNDER REGULATIO...
23 Oct 2015 09:24

CYPRUS: SERVICE OF COURT DOCUMENTS UNDER REGULATION (EC) 1393/2007    In a case [ ... ]

read more
CYPRUS: APPOINTMENT OF RECEIVER IN AID OF EQUITABL...
21 Oct 2015 13:59

CYPRUS: APPOINTMENT OF RECEIVER IN AID OF EQUITABLE EXECUTION OF CYPRUS JUDGMENT   I [ ... ]

read more
Cyprus : Supreme Court has ruled in favour of Spee...
20 Oct 2015 10:19

Cyprus : Supreme Court has ruled in favour of Speed and Efficacy in the spirit of judicial cooper [ ... ]

read more
CYPRUS: Strengthening protection on money launderi...
19 Oct 2015 13:43

CYPRUS: Strengthening protection on money laundering by the Introduction of the Fourth Anti-  [ ... ]

read more
The International Court of Arbitration of the Inte...
13 Oct 2015 05:54

The International Court of Arbitration of the International Chamber of Commerce to communicate re [ ... ]

read more
A fight against corruption by the proposed introdu...
05 Oct 2015 06:12

A fight against corruption by the proposed introduction of Criminal Record Certificates for Companie [ ... ]

read more
THE EXAMINERSHIP - Amendments to the Cyprus Legisl...
30 Sep 2015 07:36

THE EXAMINERSHIP - Amendments to the Cyprus Legislation     The Compan [ ... ]

read more
CYPRUS TAX. AMENDMENTS EXPECTED TO ARRIVE IN AUTUM...
23 Sep 2015 06:24

CYPRUS TAX. AMENDMENTS EXPECTED TO ARRIVE IN AUTUMN 2015.   A. Income Tax Treatment  [ ... ]

read more
Changes to the Inheritance process under European ...
10 Sep 2015 10:30

  Changes to the Inheritance process under European Succession Regulation 650/2012 & [ ... ]

read more
Renewal and Amendment of the Double Taxation Treat...
09 Sep 2015 12:35

Renewal and Amendment of the Double Taxation Treaty between Cyprus and Ukraine   ___ [ ... ]

read more
ACTIVATION OF A CIF AUTHORISATION
01 Sep 2015 09:25

ACTIVATION OF A CIF AUTHORISATION   According to Cyprus Securities and Exchange Comm [ ... ]

read more
RECENT DEVELOPMENTS IN CYPRUS DTT NETWORK
01 Sep 2015 09:23

RECENT DEVELOPMENTS IN CYPRUS DTT NETWORK   Cyprus- Bahrain (DTT signed in March 201 [ ... ]

read more
CYPRUS INVESTMENT FIRMS (CIFs)
01 Sep 2015 09:16

CYPRUS INVESTMENT FIRMS (CIFs)   The Cyprus Investment Firms Law 144(I)/2007 provide [ ... ]

read more
The establishment of a New Administrative Court in...
19 Aug 2015 05:55

The establishment of a New Administrative Court in Nicosia, Cyprus     &nbs [ ... ]

read more
The Approval of a Bill relating to the Sale of Loa...
06 Aug 2015 06:43

The Approval of a Bill relating to the Sale of Loans   A bill under the name &ldquo [ ... ]

read more
Recent Amendments to Cyprus Tax Regime
23 Jul 2015 06:41

Recent Amendments to Cyprus Tax Regime   On the 9th July 2015, Cyprus Parliament passed number of [ ... ]

read more
Cyprus – Immovable Property
20 Jul 2015 09:30

Cyprus –Immovable Property     ‘Parliament to submit law addres [ ... ]

read more
The Law amending the Companies Law CAP 113 N.4 [89...
16 Jul 2015 06:31

The Law amending the Companies Law CAP 113 N.4 [89(I) /2015] and collectively (the ‘Law’) came i [ ... ]

read more
Scheme for Naturalisation of Investors in Cyprus
30 Mar 2015 09:38

EU PASSPORT   Scheme for Naturalisation of Investors in Cyprus     The Council of Ministers  [ ... ]

read more
The new features under the Recast Regulation 1215/...
24 Mar 2015 07:02

The new features under the Recast Regulation 1215/2012     The significance of the EU Regulatio [ ... ]

read more
Lis Alibi Pendens under the Council Regulation (EC...
02 Feb 2015 10:50

Lis Alibi Pendens under the Council Regulation (EC) No 44/2001 on jurisdictionand the recognition an [ ... ]

read more
More Publications 2015

Subscribe to our Publications

Image
We are dedicated to providing our clients with outstanding, highly personalized, legal representation.
Chrysanthou Mylona 10 
3030 - Limassol, Cyprus
© Soteris Pittas & Co LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Image