Directors Duties in Insolvency and its Vicinity- An Alternative Approach for Creditors to Recover

 

Cyprus: Directors Duties in Insolvency and its Vicinity- An Alternative Approach for Creditors to Recover

 

When a company enters insolvency or its ‘’vicinity’’[1], the fiduciary duties of directors are no longer owed to the company as a whole, and instead their duties shift towards the creditors. [Kinsela & Anor v Russell Kinsela Pty Ltd [1986] 4 NSWLR 722; West Mercia Safetywear Ltd v Dodd (1988) 4 BCC 30]

 

Pursuant to section 212 of Cap 113, under Cyprus law a company is deemed to be insolvent:

 

" a) If a statutory demand for an undisputed and liquidated amount, exceeding (€5.000), is left unpaid for more than three weeks; or

 

b) …; or

 

c) If it is proved to the Court’s satisfaction that the company is unable to pay its debts as they fall due, having in mind its contingent and prospective liabilities (‘’the cash flow test’’) ; or

 

d) If it is proved to the Court’s satisfaction that the liabilities of the company exceed the company’s assets, having in mind its contingent and prospective liabilities; (‘’the balance sheet test’’) "

 

According to the decision in Yukong Line Ltd v Rendesburg Investments Corpn (No 2) [1998] 1 WLR 294, despite this duty shift a director cannot be sued by individual creditors because he does not owe direct fiduciary duties towards them. Therefore, actions against them are brought by the liquidator on behalf of the company, which at this point is synonymous to the creditors and not the shareholders.

 

Cyprus law, in contrast with English law does not have a wrongful trading provision similar to section 214 of the Insolvency Act 1986 (IA 1986). In summary, pursuant to s. 214 a director may be found liable for contribution to the company’s assets, if the company has gone into insolvent liquidation, and at some time before the commencement of the winding up proceedings, the director knew or ought to have known that there was no reasonable prospect of avoiding insolvency, and if he did not take every step to minimize the potential loss.

 

Even though Cyprus law does not provide a similar statutory provision, it is very likely that a similar result with that of s. 214 of IA 1986 can be achieved through the use of the West Mercia rule as a remedy. This function of the West Mercia rule is similar to that of the wrongful trading provision, but due to the fact that it is triggered earlier than the duty in s. 214, it manages to encompass managerial conduct committed at a much earlier point, and thus provides for an even more extensive application. Additionally, it is not limited to a compensatory remedy and it is not confined to winding-up proceedings. In general, when using the West Mercia rule as a remedy, to be able to recover against a director, the director must have received a benefit from the misapplication of the funds or his breach of duties.

 

An even more extensive application of the West Mercia rule as a remedy can be seen in the Australian case of Westpac Banking Corporation v Bell Group Ltd [2012] WASCA 157; (2012) 89 ACSR 1, which was concerned with the validity of transactions with creditors before formal insolvency proceedings were initiated. In short, there was a refinancing of some sort which disadvantaged some creditors over others, and the court even though it concluded that it amounted to preferences, it found that it was not susceptible to an attack under the Australian law preference rules, because it took place outside the period of six months prior to the commencement of the formal insolvency proceedings. Since no successful claim for recovery could be based on the preferences provisions, it was contended that the Bell Group’s directors in going through with the refinancing were in violation of their fiduciary duties to the creditors, based on the Australian corresponding rule with that in West Mercia.

 

Unlike other cases which applied the West Mercia rule as a remedy, the Westpac v Bell Group decision is particularly important for the fact that it did not require as a condition, evidence that the directors had received an advantage from this scheme. Even though under this formulation of the West Mercia rule there can be no compensation order against the directors since the corporation does not suffer a loss and the directors have not benefited personally, it may nevertheless leave them vulnerable for disqualification and it also opens a route for recovery from creditors who dishonestly assisted in the breach.

 

In summary, the West Mercia rule can allow creditors to recover debt owed to them despite the lack of provisions like s. 214 IA 1986, statutory limitations and difficulties surrounding the area of insolvency. Its function as a remedy can allow a creditor to recover from the directors for breach of their duties, or even provide a way to claim against other creditors for dishonest assistance.

 

For now, this function of the West Mercia rule does not seem to have come for examination before the court, but the fact that authoritative cases like West Mercia v Dodd and Kinsela v Russell Kinsela have been cited with acceptance by Cyprus courts, shows promise that such an approach can be adopted.

 

* [1] The terms ‘’vicinity of insolvency’’ or ‘’twilight zone’’ are used interchangeably to refer to the gap that exists between the period when a company is regarded as doubtful solvent and up to the point it is found to be insolvent under section 212.

 

For further information on this topic please contact

Mr. Kyriakos Pittas( kpittas@pittaslegal.com) at SOTERIS PITTAS & CO LLC,

by telephone (+357 25 028460) or by fax (+357 25 028461)

 

 

The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advise should be sought about your specific circumstances.

PUBLICATIONS 2019

Thursday, 19 December 2019 11:55

  CYPRUS: NO PHARMACAL ORDERS WHEN THERE IS AN INFRINGEMENT OF THE “MERE WITNESS” RULE.   In the English case AXA EQUITY & LAW LIFE –V- NATIONAL WESTMINISTER BANK (1998) CHC 117 (which has...

Tuesday, 17 December 2019 09:03

  Cyprus: Deadlock at the Level of Board of Directors and the Power of the General Meeting to Act Despite Provisions in the Articles of Association Reserving the Matter for the Board   According...

Friday, 06 December 2019 12:03

  CYPRUS: JURISDICTION OF THE CYPRUS COURTS TO GRANT INTERIM RELIEF IN AID AND/OR IN SUPPORT OF PROCEEDINGS PENDING BEFORE THE COURTS OF MEMBER STATES, OR IN AID AND/OR IN SUPPORT OF FOREIGN...

Tuesday, 19 November 2019 09:09

  Cyprus: New Double Tax Treaty between Cyprus and Egypt   On the 8th of October 2019, Cyprus and the Arab Republic of Egypt have signed a new Double Tax Treaty between them, which will update...

Friday, 15 November 2019 10:20

  Cyprus: Duties and Liabilities of ‘’Nominee Directors’’   The Law Commission in its Consultation Paper on Directors’ Duties 1998 (CP 153), explained the term ‘’nominee director’’ as referring...

Friday, 08 November 2019 08:46

  CYPRUS: AN ANTISUIT INJUNCTION ISSUED BY AN ARBITRAL TRIBUNAL DOES NOT VIOLATE THE EU REGULATION 44/2001 (which has been replaced by EU Reg. 1215/12).   In its judgment in Gazprom case, the...

Tuesday, 05 November 2019 12:22

  GCEU ruling for arbitral award considered as illegal state aid: Micula brothers v. Government of Romania   On 18th of June 2019, the GCEU issued a judgement in the Micula Case, between European...

Wednesday, 30 October 2019 10:21

  AN INTERNATIONAL ARBITRAL AWARD MAY BE RECOGNIZED AND ENFORCED, EITHER BY THE SUMMARY PROCESS STATED IN THE NEW YORK CONVENTION, OR AT COMMON LAW, BY FILING OF A CIVIL ACTION BASED ON THE...

Friday, 25 October 2019 11:46

  CYPRUS: THE EFFECT OF A JUDGMENT BY A COURT OF SUPERVISORY JURISDICTION AT THE SEAT OF ARBITRATION, ON THE VALIDITY, LEGALITY AND ENFORCEABILITY OF ARBITRAL AWARDS IN THE ENFORCING COUNTRIES  ...

Tuesday, 22 October 2019 12:22

  CYPRUS: Common Law Tort of Conspiracy   Conspiracy is recognized in Cyprus as a common law tort.   The Supreme Court of Cyprus in CHRISTOFOROU & OTHERS -V- BARCLAYS BANK PLC (2009), held...

Monday, 14 October 2019 12:58

  Cyprus: Achieving Re-domiciliation of Companies in Jurisdictions that do not provide ‘’Pure Re-domiciliation’’ Procedures   Jurisdictions such as Cyprus, BVI, Delaware, Luxembourg and...

Wednesday, 09 October 2019 08:57

  CYPRUS: Breach of an injunction constitutes unlawful means Conspiracy   In the recent English case JSC BTA BANK -V- KHRAPUNOV (2018), the Supreme Court, held inter alia, that third parties may...

Tuesday, 08 October 2019 14:44

  The 5th EU Anti-Money laundering Directive   Money laundering, terrorism financing and organized crime consist significant problems, addressed at Union Level, as money launderers usually take...

Wednesday, 25 September 2019 09:05

  CYPRUS: The Chabra jurisdiction of Cypriot Courts   In the case GDL TRADING LTD -V- AGROMARKETS LTD & OTHERS, the District Court of Nicosia inter alia held – (adopting English case law) -...

Monday, 23 September 2019 10:39

  Time limitation in Enforcing an Arbitral Award   Arbitral awards are enforceable in Cyprus under the provisions of the Cypriot Law on International Arbitration in Commercial Matters Law No....

Monday, 09 September 2019 12:39

  CYPRUS: Useful guidance for Cypriot courts as to their jurisdiction to control the manner in which a Party obtains evidence to support its case   In the English case SOUTH CAROLINA INSURANCE CO...

Thursday, 29 August 2019 11:09

  Draft Bill for Memo on property for social insurance debts   A draft bill that has been put forward before the House of Representatives relating to the seizure and foreclosure of movable...

Thursday, 25 July 2019 14:46

  CYPRUS: Methods of Enforcement of an Arbitral Award in the Republic of Cyprus   A successful party in an arbitration may find the losing party unwilling to honor the arbitral award.   The...

Thursday, 18 July 2019 16:39

  CYPRUS: INHERENT JURISDICTION OF CYPRIOT COURT TO STAY ENFORCEMENT PROCEEDINGS OF AN ARBITRAL AWARD   In the leading Appellate case, Attorney General of The Republic of Kenya -v- Bank Fur...

Wednesday, 17 July 2019 11:22

  New Hague Convention for the enforcement of foreign judgments   On the 2nd July 2019, the Hague Conference on Private International Law finalized a new treaty on enforcement of judgments (“the...

Thursday, 11 July 2019 14:38

  Supreme Court examines Article IV of New York Convention overturning First Instance Judgment   In a recent Supreme Court case, the court examined whether the first instance judge as was the...

Tuesday, 25 June 2019 12:31

  CYPRUS: LOCUS STANDING OF A FOREIGN LIQUIDATOR OR FOREIGN COURT APPOINTED INTERIM RECEIVER TO FILE COURTS PROCEEDINGS BEFORE CYPRUS COURT   The Supreme Court of Cyprus in the leading case...

Thursday, 20 June 2019 09:56

  CYPRUS: NEW LAW FOR CERTIFIED TRANSLATORS   Up until now, official translations in Cyprus were solely carried out by the Press and Information Office via its translators’ associates, but...

Thursday, 30 May 2019 09:47

  CYPRUS: Cypriot Courts do not have jurisdiction to grant anti-suit injunctions in aid of arbitral proceedings pursuant to Section 9 of Law 101/87 (UNCITRAL MODEL LAW).   The Supreme Court of...

Wednesday, 22 May 2019 10:30

  Cyprus: The amendments to CAP 113. Update. PART 2. Strike-Off   Effective as of 18 December 2018:   Strike - Off S. 327(5).   Amendments relating to the strike-off of a company Members...

Monday, 13 May 2019 12:51

  Cyprus: The amendments to CAP 113. Update. PART 1   Effective as of 18 December 2018:   (1) The abolition of Capital Duty The Council of Ministers abolished the obligation to pay capital...

Friday, 19 April 2019 09:59

  Cyprus. Disposals of Land. Applicability of VAT to Land Disposal Transactions   The bill, which came into force on 2nd January 2018, has amended the Value Added Tax Law (95(I)/2000) (the “VAT...

Tuesday, 16 April 2019 14:42

  Cyprus: Company Law – Power of court to rectify the Register of Members of a Cyprus company   It has been held by Cypriot courts (adopting English case law) that the power of court to order the...

Tuesday, 09 April 2019 10:12

  Cyprus: Requirements for obtaining a Chabra injunction   In the case of Re Nicolaou Bros Tourist Enterprises Ltd (1999) 1 AAD 201, the Supreme Court of Cyprus, by adopting English legal...

Friday, 29 March 2019 10:19

  Cyprus Tax Authorities introduce guidance for taxation of Intra-Group Financing Transactions.   In Cyprus Transfer Pricing rules are regulated by the circular issued on 30 June 2017 by the...

Friday, 15 March 2019 09:21

  Cyprus: Directors Duties in Insolvency and its Vicinity- An Alternative Approach for Creditors to Recover   When a company enters insolvency or its ‘’vicinity’’[1], the fiduciary duties of...

Wednesday, 13 March 2019 16:19

  Amendments to the Cyprus Investment Scheme   Certain significant amendments have been made to the Cyprus Investment Scheme whereby the Government has taken a step to limit the program, even...

Friday, 01 March 2019 09:05

  Cyprus: Enforcing Specific Performance Orders made by Arbitral Tribunals   Generally, in international commercial arbitrations the remedy which is most commonly sought and which is usually...

Wednesday, 13 February 2019 16:18

  Cyprus – UK/Cyprus Double Taxation Convention   On 19 December 2018, the Cyprus Minister of Finance, Harris Georgiades and the British High Commissioner to Cyprus, Stephen Lillie, signed a...

Tuesday, 05 February 2019 11:49

  Cyprus: Intellectual Property - Efficient IP Regime   Soteris Pittas & Co LLC has observed an increase in the amounts of the IP asset registrations that are taking place. One may wonder...

Thursday, 24 January 2019 15:55

  CYPRUS: STAY OF WINDING UP PROCEEDINGS AGAINST A CYPRIOT COMPANY DUE TO ARBITRATION AGREEMENT   In a recent decision, in the case ERIN -V- RAYHILL, the District Court of Limassol decided to...

Thursday, 10 January 2019 11:35

  CYPRUS: The Arbitral Claim in whose support interim relief has been granted as per Section 9 of Law 101/87 by Cypriot Courts, shall be filed within reasonable time   In the case CFG CAPITAL...

Subscribe to our Publications

Image
We are dedicated to providing our clients with outstanding, highly personalized, legal representation.
Chrysanthou Mylona 10 
3030 - Limassol, Cyprus
© Soteris Pittas & Co LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Image