Cyprus: Risks for advancing money by way of a loan and the protection offered by the Quistclose trust

 

Cyprus: Risks for advancing money by way of a loan and the protection offered by the Quistclose trust

 

The rule in relation to money advanced by way of a loan, is that generally they become the property of the borrower, giving him the discretion to apply the money as he thinks fit, and leaving the lender vulnerable to the risk of the borrower’s insolvency.

The Quistclose trust which emerged from the case of Barclay’s Bank Ltd v Quistclose Ltd constitutes a kind of exception to this rule. The House of Lords in this case decided that money lent for a purpose is held by the borrower on trust for the lender, if that purpose is not achieved. A Quistclose trust is said to give rise to a two-pronged trust. First, an express trust in favour of the creditors, based on the mutual intention of the lender and the borrower that the sum advanced should be used solely for the purpose stated, and a second, in favour of the lender, that only arises upon the failure of the first one.

 

Retention of Title clauses (ROT’s), extent to cover past and previous debts owed to the seller and allow the buyer to manage the goods however he likes. Unlike them, the Quistclose trust only covers the one debt and provides strict instructions that regulate the funds’ use.

 

It is a convenient tool for corporate rescue, due to the fact that by providing security to the lender of an insolvent company, it means that lenders are more inclined and willing to agree to give such loans that can many times be fundamental in extricating a company from financial difficulties. This is because a lender under a Quistclose trust has priority over the unsecured creditors to recover the owed sum, and he does not await a pari passu distribution of the available assets.

 

The 2002 decision of the House of Lords in Twinsectra v Yardley has refocused attention on the Quistclose trust and made it a type of trust of a more general application. Lord Millet in this case held that the duty arising is not a contractual one but a fiduciary, since it is unconscionable for a party to obtain money on terms as to its application and then disregard them. In these situations a relationship of trust and confidence is created, based on the assumption that the money will be applied by the recipient for the proper, or otherwise agreed purpose.

 

The conclusion reached from Lord Millet’s statements in Twinsectra is that there is no need for an express trust to be set up to be able to prove the intended purpose, and that in the absence of it a resulting trust may arise in favour of the lender, thus broadening the circumstances in which the court may be inclined to find a Quistclose trust to exist.

 

As it was affirmed in 2015 by the Court of Appeal in Bellis v Challinor, taking into consideration inter alia the above authorities, the Court when examining whether a Quistclose trust arises, will focus on the true construction of the words used by the transferor, and if no such words exist, but he responds to an invitation to transfer the property on terms, then the true construction of the invitation will likely be the decisive factor.

 

Nevertheless, it is important to note that this vehicle is a creation of equity that exists in common law jurisdictions including Cyprus, and therefore it is in the discretion of the judiciary whether on the facts of the case a Quistclose trust may arise.

 

For further information on this topic please contact

Mr. Kyriakos Pittas (kpittas@pittaslegal.com) at SOTERIS PITTAS & CO LLC,

by telephone (+357 25 028460) or by fax (+357 25 028461)

 

 

The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advise should be sought about your specific circumstances.

PUBLICATIONS 2017

THE EU LIST of non-cooperative tax jurisdictions
27 Dec 2017 09:05

  THE EU LIST of non-cooperative tax jurisdictions   During their meeting in Brussels on the 5t [ ... ]

read more
CYPRUS: VAT LAW AMENDMENT
12 Dec 2017 06:50

  CYPRUS: VAT LAW AMENDMENT   On the 3rd of November 2017 the Cypriot Parliament amended the VA [ ... ]

read more
CYPRUS: The Cypriot Admiralty Court does not have ...
05 Dec 2017 06:56

  CYPRUS: The Cypriot Admiralty Court does not have jurisdiction to issue a warrant of arrest of a [ ... ]

read more
Cyprus: Tax residency amendment
23 Nov 2017 10:53

  Cyprus: Tax residency amendment   The Parliament of Cyprus has approved on the 14th of July  [ ... ]

read more
LAW, AMENDING THE RIGHTS OF PERSONS ARRESTED AND D...
17 Nov 2017 06:56

  LAW, AMENDING THE RIGHTS OF PERSONS ARRESTED AND DETAINED ACT OF 2005 AND 2014 22(I)/2017    [ ... ]

read more
CYPRUS: District Court of Limassol dismisses origi...
31 Oct 2017 07:27

  CYPRUS: District Court of Limassol dismisses originating application for cross examination of an [ ... ]

read more
CYPRUS: Does the principle of res judicata apply t...
20 Oct 2017 07:09

  CYPRUS: Does the principle of res judicata apply to arbitral awards?   In the case of Cruz Ci [ ... ]

read more
CYPRUS: Personal criminal liability when issuing a...
11 Oct 2017 07:48

  CYPRUS: Personal criminal liability when issuing a cheque on behalf of the company   A bounci [ ... ]

read more
CYPRUS: A decision of English Court recognizing an...
05 Oct 2017 09:00

  CYPRUS: A decision of English Court recognizing an arbitral award, cannot be recognised and enfo [ ... ]

read more
Cyprus: The Amendments to the Companies Law Cap 11...
26 Sep 2017 07:13

  Cyprus: The Amendments to the Companies Law Cap 113   The House of Representatives has approv [ ... ]

read more
CYPRUS: Recent development shows a willingness of ...
20 Sep 2017 06:16

  CYPRUS: Recent development shows a willingness of Cypriot Courts to issue orders permitting the  [ ... ]

read more
CYPRUS - Amendments to the Advocates (Amendment) L...
07 Sep 2017 09:25

  CYPRUS - Amendments to the Advocates (Amendment) Law of 2017, Law 92(I)/2017   Significant am [ ... ]

read more
Cyprus: The implementation of the EU posted worker...
28 Aug 2017 08:30

  Cyprus: The implementation of the EU posted workers directive   The Republic of Cyprus has im [ ... ]

read more
CYPRUS: The automatic increase in child support is...
03 Aug 2017 08:15

  CYPRUS: The automatic increase in child support is not unconstitutional   It had been recentl [ ... ]

read more
Cyprus: Risks for advancing money by way of a loan...
25 Jul 2017 09:26

  Cyprus: Risks for advancing money by way of a loan and the protection offered by the Quistclose  [ ... ]

read more
CYPRUS - TAX UPDATE – TAX RESIDENCY RULES TO BE AM...
19 Jul 2017 08:21

  CYPRUS - TAX UPDATE – TAX RESIDENCY RULES TO BE AMENDED   On 14th July 2017, the Parliament [ ... ]

read more
CYPRUS: General Guidance on aspects of breach of c...
13 Jul 2017 11:49

  CYPRUS: General Guidance on aspects of breach of contract issues before pursuing litigation    [ ... ]

read more
CYPRUS: Guidance from the Supreme Court on the res...
05 Jul 2017 12:01

CYPRUS: Guidance from the Supreme Court on the responsibility of directors of companies as to the is [ ... ]

read more
CYPRUS: Guidance on the issue of independency of e...
21 Jun 2017 07:33

CYPRUS: Guidance on the issue of independency of expert witnesses   The well-known aspect of inde [ ... ]

read more
CYPRUS: The Arbitration Court in Stockholm rejects...
16 Jun 2017 06:23

CYPRUS: The Arbitration Court in Stockholm rejects the appeal against the Cyprus’ 2013 recapital [ ... ]

read more
The amended law on Specific Performance relating t...
07 Jun 2017 06:00

The amended law on Specific Performance relating to Property Sales   Recently, the law of Specif [ ... ]

read more
Cyprus - Dispute Resolution – Commercial Court
15 May 2017 11:47

Cyprus- Dispute Resolution – Commercial Court Minister of Justice, Mr. Ionas Nicolaou and Member [ ... ]

read more
Cyprus – Tax –Notional Interest Deduction (the “NI...
25 Apr 2017 07:30

Cyprus – Tax –Notional Interest Deduction (the “NID”) and Circular 2016/10   The NID rule [ ... ]

read more
Cyprus – Tax-Immovable Property Tax Law
09 Feb 2017 06:39

Cyprus – Tax-Immovable Property Tax Law   On 14 July 2016, the House of Representatives approve [ ... ]

read more
More Publications 2017

Subscribe to our Publications

Image
We are dedicated to providing our clients with outstanding, highly personalized, legal representation.
Chrysanthou Mylona 10 
3030 - Limassol, Cyprus
© Soteris Pittas & Co LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Image