CYPRUS: ADMIRALTY AND SHIPPING - PIRACY AND PAYMENT OF RANSOM FOR RELEASE OF SHIPS UNDER CYPRUS FLAG.

The existence and nature of piratical attacks off Somalia, is a matter of great notoriety and has caused tremendous problems to ship-owners, cargo-owners, insurers, crew members etc. 


Due to the absence of any effective government, or law enforcement in Somalia, the only realistic and effective manner of obtaining release of a vessel seized by the Somali pirates, is the negotiation and payment of a ransom.


Is the payment of ransom to Somali pirates for obtaining the release of a vessel seized, unlawful and/or contrary to public policy?


Cyprus has been an independent and sovereign republic, since 1960. Until that time, it had been a British Colony. The Cypriot legal system followed English law until 1960. Since then, it has been closely modeled on its English counterpart. Cyprus has adopted the Anglo-Saxon legal system, which allows most English cases to be cited in Cypriot Courts. Under certain conditions, the cases are treated as binding, but in most instances, they are used as guidelines.


There is no Cypriot case law, on the issue under consideration, neither there is any legislation rendering the payment of ransom unlawful.


In the event that an issue is raised before Cypriot Courts for consideration, Cypriot Courts will follow and adopt legal principles laid down in English case law.


In the English Appellate case MASEFIELD AG –V- AMLIN COPROPRATE MEMBER LTD (2011) EWCA CIV 24, it has been inter alia held that:


(1) There is no universal morality against the payment of ransom, the act not of the aggressor but of the victim of piratical threats, performed in order to save property and the liberty or life of hostages. This is despite the realization that the payment of ransom, whatever it might achieve in terms of the rescue of hostages and property, itself encourages the incident of piracy for the purposes of exacting more ransoms (per RIX LJ at paragraph 69).

 

(2) There is no universally recognized principle of morality, no clearly identified public policy, no incontestable public interest, which could lead the courts, as a matter which stands beyond the pale, without any legitimate recognition. There are only elements of conflicting public interests, which push and pull in different directions and have yet to be resolved in any legal enactments or international consensus as to a solution (per RIX LJ at paragraph 71).

 

(3) The payment of ransom was not of itself contrary to English public policy.

 

Relying on inter alia the above, we conclude that it is lawful, as a matter of Cypriot law, to pay a ransom to Somali pirates, in order to secure the release of a ship, her crew and cargo.
 

 

 

 

For further information on this topic please contact

Mr. Soteris Pittas( spittas@pittaslegal.com ) at SOTERIS PITTAS & CO LLC,

by telephone (+357 25 028460) or by fax (+357 25 028461)

 

 

The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advise should be sought about your specific circumstances.

 

PUBLICATIONS 2012

Cyprus and Ukraine signed a new bilateral tax agre...
12 Nov 2012 22:51

  Cyprus and Ukraine signed a new bilateral tax agreement for the avoidance of double taxation and [ ... ]

read more
CYPRUS: Dispute arising out from a Shareholders Ag...
16 Oct 2012 16:21

  CYPRUS: Dispute arising out from a Shareholders Agreement containing an arbitration clause - App [ ... ]

read more
CYPRUS: Anti-Suit Injunction issued by Arbitral Tr...
16 Oct 2012 16:20

CYPRUS: Anti-Suit Injunction issued by Arbitral Tribunal in an LCIA arbitration case conducted in Lo [ ... ]

read more
CYPRUS: THIRD PARTY LITIGATION FUNDING, ASSIGNMENT...
10 Sep 2012 16:24

The legality of a third party litigation funding, has not yet been examined by Cypriot Courts.    [ ... ]

read more
CYPRUS: ENFORCEMENT AND REGISTRATION OF AN UKRAINI...
24 Jul 2012 16:27

  CYPRUS: ENFORCEMENT AND REGISTRATION OF AN UKRAINIAN JUDGMENT AND THE POSSIBILITY OF OBTAINING I [ ... ]

read more
Intra Group Loans (back-to back loans) through Cyp...
20 Jul 2012 17:07

Cyprus Companies are in wide use as major vehicles in international tax structuring mainly due to th [ ... ]

read more
The Power of Revocation of a Settlor of a Discreti...
09 Jul 2012 16:37

In the TASSARRUF MEVDUATI SEGORTA FONU -v- MERRIL LYNCH BANK AND TRUST COMPANY (CAYMAN) LTD & O [ ... ]

read more
CYPRUS: Enforcement of Foreign Judgments
29 May 2012 16:45

INTRODUCTION Cyprus does not have a formal policy towards the recognition and enforcement of foreig [ ... ]

read more
District Court of Limassol Rules that Fraudulent D...
29 May 2012 16:43

District Court of Limassol Rules that Fraudulent Disposal of Assets of a Ukrainian Company Cannot be [ ... ]

read more
CYPRUS : Enforcement of International Arbitral Awa...
02 May 2012 16:48

The Republic of Cyprus is a Contracting party to New York Convention.   Since December 1980 the R [ ... ]

read more
CYPRUS: Enforcement and Registration of a Russian ...
02 May 2012 16:46

INTRODUCTION    The registration and enforcement of a Russian judgment in the Republic of Cyprus [ ... ]

read more
CYPRUS: ADMIRALTY AND SHIPPING - PIRACY AND PAYMEN...
08 Feb 2012 16:51

The existence and nature of piratical attacks off Somalia, is a matter of great notoriety and has ca [ ... ]

read more
CYPRUS: CAN EX PARTE NORWICH PHARMACAL ORDERS BE S...
30 Jan 2012 16:58

In the recent case PENDERHIL HOLDINGS LTD –V- IOANNI KLOUKINA,  the Supreme Court of Cyprus, exa [ ... ]

read more
CYPRUS: ARBITRATION AND DERIVATIVE ACTIONS
30 Jan 2012 16:57

In a recent decision of the Supreme Court of Cyprus, it has been held, that a derivative action file [ ... ]

read more
CYPRUS: Appointment of an equitable receiver in ai...
30 Jan 2012 16:55

In the context of an application to register and enforce a Russian judgment, pursuant  to the terms [ ... ]

read more
CYPRUS: New Limitation Law
10 Jan 2012 17:41

All jurisdictions apply particular limitation periods for an action to be filed. In Cyprus limitatio [ ... ]

read more
More Publications 2012

Subscribe to our Publications

Image
We are dedicated to providing our clients with outstanding, highly personalized, legal representation.
Chrysanthou Mylona 10 
3030 - Limassol, Cyprus
© Soteris Pittas & Co LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Image