SOTERIS PITTAS & CO LLC is a boutique law firm, in size only, focusing on the areas of law related to business activity and dedicated to providing its clients with outstanding, highly personalized, legal representation. Profile

Our lawyers are specialized in dispute resolution of complicate and multi-jurisdictional commercial and corporate disputes and they have been involved in all major litigation disputes raised before Cypriot Courts. Practices

 

CYPRUS: Personal criminal liability when issuing a cheque on behalf of the company

 

A bouncing cheque (see Art. 305A Criminal Code - Chapter 154) is an offence of strict liability for its issuer. Therefore, the prosecutor needs to prove only the below elements (actus reus):

 

(1) The issuing of a cheque;

 

(2) That the cheque was presented, on or after its due date, at the relevant Bank;

 

(3) The non-payment of the cheque due to lack of available funds of the issuer or due to the fact that the issuer's account was closed at the time of presentation;

 

(4) The non-payment of the cheque for a period of 15 days of its first presentation.

 

When it comes to a bouncing cheque issued by a company, then the signatory of the cheque (most probably its Director) could be liable as an accomplice to the offence of Art. 305A, according to Art. 20 (c) of the Criminal Code.

 

However, the actus reus of an accomplice includes: a) assistance or motivation b) to an offense; mens rea (guilty mind) is expected to be related to both elements (see Pavlopoulos V. Skopy Show Factory (2003) 2 CLR 261).

 

In Johnson v. Youden [1950] 1 K.B. 455 it was stated that “before a person can be convicted of aiding and abetting the commission of an offence, he must at least know the essential matters which constitute that offence", and also in National Coal Board v. Gamble [1959] 1 K.B. 11 it was stated that “… aiding and abetting is a crime that requires proof of mens rea, that is to say, of intention to aid as well as of knowledge of the circumstances").

 

Given the above, difficulties arise when it comes to evidencing that the signatory of a company’s cheque, provided aid to the commission of a crime, especially when it comes to large companies with accounting departments, CFOs and postdated cheques.

 

Firstly, in order to prove that the signatory had the needed mens rea, when executing the cheque on behalf of the company, the prosecution needs to prove the time of the signing. Only when the time of the signing is known, the prosecution can provide evidence proving, that at the time of the signing of the cheque, the signatory knew or owed to had known that the cheque would bounce.

 

Wilful blindness

 

“A requirement of knowledge is sometimes held to be satisfied by proof of "wilful blindness" as where "the defendant had deliberately shut his eyes to the obvious or refrained from inquiry because he suspected the truth but did not want to have his suspicion confirmed" (Westminster City Council v. Croyalgrange [1986] 2 All E.R. 353 at p. 359 (H.L.) (see HENRY HARRY HODFIELD V. Customs Department (2002) 2 CLR 414).

According to the above, the willful blindness of a defendant, i.e. when he is willfully shutting his eyes to the obvious, then such behavior is not excusable and is criminally liable.

 

Recklessness

 

In a very recent and interesting case (see Ioannide V. Gastop Boutique Ltd a.a. 161/2014, 30/6/2017) it was stated that: “… it does not seem necessary to prove the intention on the part of the accomplice to commit the principal offense” ... “It is sufficient, in our judgment, if the accomplice knew the facts constituting the principal offense of issuing a bouncing cheque and was indifferent or reckless with regard to whether the cheque would be paid when it was presented to the Bank for payment.” … “Therefore, neither the non-involvement of the respondent 2 in the company's daily financial statements nor the promise, general and vague, of her husband, that he would deposit the money he would receive from a court case, on the account of the company from which the cheque was issued, could be a defense for the respondent 2 …”

 

In Smith and Hogan’s Criminal Law it is stated that the Primary meaning of “wilful” is “deliberate” but it may also include recklessness, as accepted by the majority of the House of Lords in Sheppard (1981 AC 394). It is also said that a person who does not intend to cause a harmful result may take an unjustified risk of causing it. If he does so, he may be held to be reckless.

 

 

For further information on this topic please contact

Mr. Antonis Alexopoulos (aalexopoulos@pittaslegal.com) at SOTERIS PITTAS & CO LLC,

by telephone (+357 25 028460) or by fax (+357 25 028461)

 

 

The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advise should be sought about your specific circumstances.

PUBLICATIONS

NEWS

  • 21 Mar 2017

    METHODS OF PAYMENT / OTHER INSTRUMENTS - In House Seminar

  • 21 Mar 2017

    EU Regulation 655/14 - In House Seminar

  • 3 Mar 2017

    Update from the Registrar of Companies and Official Receiver

  • 22 Feb 2017

    LAWYER MONTHLY LEGAL AWARDS - Corporate Law Firm of the Year 2016 in Cyprus

  • 13 Feb 2017

    Update on the collection of information of financial instruments offered by the Cyprus Investment Firm

  • 22 Dec 2016

    DELETION OF COMPANIES DUE TO NON PAYMENT OF ANNUAL LEVY

  • 19 Dec 2016

    CHRISTMAS - NEW YEAR PREPARATIONS 2016-2017

  • 13 Dec 2016

    MEA Markets Business Awards 2016 - BOUTIQUE LAW FIRM of the year in Cyprus

  • 22 Nov 2016

    ORDER 30 OF THE CIVIL PROCEDURES RULES - In House Seminar

  • 9 Nov 2016

    SERVICE OF COURT DOCUMENTS - In House Seminar

  • 10 Oct 2016

    Cyprus- Health-NHS System

  • 4 Oct 2016

    CYPRUS PRIVATISATION OF THE CSE

  • 3 Oct 2016

    ACQUISITION INTERNATIONAL Awards 2016 - CORPORATE ADVISER of the year in Cyprus

  • 23 Sep 2016

    ACQ Global Awards 2016 - Corporate and Commercial LAW FIRM of the year in Cyprus

  • 20 Sep 2016

    No interest to buy loans from BoC - CySec

  • 15 Sep 2016

    The Cabinet has approved on Tuesday (13.0916) the revised scheme for granting Cypriot citizenship to non–Cypriot entrepreneurs/investors.

  • 30 May 2016

    Cyprus Investment Firms (CIFs) - In House Seminar

  • 24 May 2016

    Private Equity Law Firm of the year by CorporateINTL Global Awards 2016

  • 23 May 2016

    Due Diligence for Real Estate Conveyance - In House Seminar

  • 18 Apr 2016

    Ammendments in orders 25 & 30 - In House Seminar

  • 12 Apr 2016

    Participation of our members at the 5 Km Marathon - Run with Smile in Limassol

  • 7 Mar 2016

    Fire Protection and Safety - Training

  • 8 Feb 2016

    Highly Recommended Lawyer by Chambers Global Clients Guide 2016

  • 21 Dec 2015

    BASIC PRINCIPLES OF CORPORATE LAW - In House Seminar

  • 16 Dec 2015

    CHRISTMAS - NEW YEAR PREPARATIONS 2015-2016

  • 9 Dec 2015

    Mr. Soteris Pittas roundtable discussion with law students of UCLAN University - Cyprus

  • 1 Dec 2015

    Case Management - In House Seminar

  • 13 Nov 2015

    CONFERENCE “KIЕV ARBITRATION DAYS 2015: "THINK BIG"

  • 12 Nov 2015

    Mondaq's Contributor Most Read in Cyprus Award October 2015

  • 3 Nov 2015

    Our MD Mr. Soteris Pittas attended a seminar organised by the Ukrainian Bar Association and the Association of Judges of Ukraine in Kiev 02-11-2015

  • 27 Oct 2015

    Recent changes in Companies Law - in house seminar

  • 22 Oct 2015

    Acquisition International Best Boutique Law Firm - Cyprus Award

  • 28 Sep 2015

    Introduction to the Anti-Money Laundering Legislation - In house Seminar

  • 18 Dec 2014

    FIRST AID training session - Defibrillator

  • 18 Dec 2014

    CHRISTMAS - NEW YEAR PREPARATIONS 2014-2015

  • 11 Nov 2014

    CONFERENCE “KIЕV ARBITRATION DAYS 2014: "THINK BIG"

  • 21 Jul 2014

    25 years of progress – Grand Opening of New Premises (Press Release)

  • 10 Dec 2013

    CHRISTMAS - NEW YEAR PREPARATIONS 2013-2014

  • 21 Nov 2013

    Sponsor in Charity Event

  • 15 Oct 2013

    Participation of our members to charity event

  • 7 Oct 2013

    INTAX EXPRO - VIII Annual Conference and Exhibition

  • 4 Oct 2013

    Conference “Dispute Resolution in M&A Transactions: Tactics, Challenges, Defences“

  • 10 Jul 2013

    “Peculiarities of disputes in Cyprus in post-M&A and shareholder disputes

  • 10 Jul 2013

    Vote of Confidence for Cyprus Banks by Russian Businessmen

  • 10 Jul 2013

    New photos of the construction for our New Premises

  • 10 Jul 2013

    Visual Photos for our New Premises

  • 10 Jul 2013

    VAT Update on the changes as from 1 January 2010 in relation to the following matters

  • 10 Jul 2013

    The visit to Cyprus of the Russian President Mr. Dmitry Medvedev.

  • 10 Jul 2013

    Participation of Members of our Law Firm in Charity Event

  • 10 Jul 2013

    New Photos of the Construction of our new premises.

  • 10 Jul 2013

    Less Bureaucracy for Business Enterprises

  • 10 Jul 2013

    Latin Legal Maxims and Phrases

  • 10 Jul 2013

    Increase of the Cyprus VAT Rate, but still the second lowest in EU

  • 10 Jul 2013

    CONFERENCE “KIЕV ARBITRATION DAYS 2012: "THINK BIG"

  • 10 Jul 2013

    Commission takes action against Cyprus and other 11 Member States to implement the Shareholder’s rights Directive

  • 10 Jul 2013

    Beginning of the Construction for our new Premises

  • 10 Jul 2013

    Agreement for the Avoidance of Double Taxation between Cyprus and Slovenia

  • 10 Jul 2013

    Agreement for the Avoidance of Double Taxation between Cyprus and Qatar

  • 10 Jul 2013

    Agreement for the Avoidance of Double Taxation between Cyprus and Kuwait.

  • 10 Jul 2013

    ABA Conference / Moscow / September 2011